Vote against Additional Protocol Oviedo Convention - Reisverslag uit Straatsburg, Frankrijk van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu Vote against Additional Protocol Oviedo Convention - Reisverslag uit Straatsburg, Frankrijk van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu

Vote against Additional Protocol Oviedo Convention

Door: Jolijn Santegoeds

Blijf op de hoogte en volg Jolijn

12 November 2021 | Frankrijk, Straatsburg

This article was originally published in Dutch on 12 November 2021. The original post can be found here: https://tekeertegendeisoleer.wordpress.com/2021/11/12/stem-tegen-het-aanvullend-protocol-voor-het-verdrag-van-oviedo/


Vote against the “Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention”

This article is about European legislation with regards to coercion in mental health care.

The Council of Europe is about to make a big mistake.

It’s now up to the minister of foreign affairs who can turn the tide with his colleagues in the Committee of Ministers in the Council of Europe.

A short explanation of the European developments on coercion legislation follows here.

Coercion in European legislation
Over the course of history, European legislation existed which allowed for the use of coercion in mental health care (ECHR art 5 and Oviedo Convention art 6 and 7). People with psychosocial problems were deprived of their liberty, for example by confinement, forced medication or restraining. This was called care.

Modern human rights
Since 2008, the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UN CRPD) applies, in which is emphasized that health status cannot be a reason for deprivation of liberty.

Coercion and deprivation of liberty in health care are in violation of human rights, such as the right to equality before the law and legal capacity (art 12), the right to liberty (art 14), the right to freedom from torture and violence (art 15 and 16), and the right to health and care on the basis of free and informed consent (art 25).

Psychosocial disabilities
Persons with psychosocial problems are persons with disabilities. The term “disabilities” does not refer to a medical condition, but to a barrier for equal participation in the community (obstacle for inclusion). Equal inclusion is a human right. A disability, or support need, cannot be a ground for deprivation of liberty.

Culture change
There is an obvious tension between the old fashioned legislation on ‘necessary coercion’ as is contained in the European and Dutch legislation on the one hand, and on the other hand, the modern human rights view from the UN Convention with the necessity to abolish coercion from health care.

Respect for human rights requires a culture shift in mental health care, and the abolition of coercion.

National politics should have given leadership to this culture shift in the Netherlands, however, they failed when they adopted the Dutch law on Mandatory Mental Health Care (WVGGZ) several years ago, which goes against the UN Convention which was ratified by the Netherlands on 14 July 2016.

Outdated view
The frequently heard call for a tough approach of ‘confused persons’ runs counter to the principles of inclusion and human rights, and is based on sensational media reports, stereotyping and discrimination. This is a sign of widespread outdated views on ‘psychiatric disorders’. Under the category of ‘medical model thinking’ people with psychosocial problems are discarded as if they were defect. Under the so called social model the focus is on “normalization” (rehabilitation). But nowadays good care is about empowerment, recovery, inclusion and diversity. The argument of ‘incapacity to consent’ is outdated. Every person has a will. It is about making contact and offering support. Better awareness raising is needed to combat outdated views. The UN Convention should be guiding the development of the health care sector.

The tough approach has been outdated for long. Unfortunately mental health care does not seem to be able to mark out the quality of care by themselves, by which the sector has become a plaything of politics and economy, and a shear post for law enforcement and budget cuts. This leads to even more human rights violations.

Under the national Dutch legislation (WVGGZ) coercion is permitted as a last resort “when there are no less restrictive alternatives possible”. By that, the availability of good care is directly connected to the degree of coercion. The waiting lists were already distressing in itself, but causing coercion is scandalous. The government fails in her task to offer protection to vulnerable citizens.

The legal position of persons who are exposed to coercion in health care is a wax nose.

Leadership is needed for the required culture shift, to make human rights come true for persons with psychosocial disabilities.

What is the Council of Europe doing?
The Council of Europe is an entity which since 1950 provides the European interpretation of the universal human rights through the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and other conventions. (The Council of Europe is separate from the European Union which was founded in 1993 as a trading union).

The Council of Europe works on further elaboration within their existing frameworks and has a number of committees to that end, as well as the European Court of Human Rights.

Draft protocol
The Committee on Bioethics of the Council of Europe has spent recent years on a draft protocol with guidelines which fit within the frameworks of the old European legislation. The draft protocol has a similar character as the Dutch law on Mandatory Mental Health Care (WVGGZ), under which coercion can only be used as a last resort, on people who due to a so called ‘mental disorder’ form a danger to themselves or others, and the whole is dressed with procedures and theoretical ‘rights’.

The full title of the document is: “Draft Additional Protocol concerning the protection of human rights and dignity of persons with mental disorder with regard to involuntary placement and involuntary treatment”.
The short title is: “Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention”.

Also see the website of the Bioethics Committee of the Council of Europe: https://www.coe.int/en/web/bioethics/-/frequently-asked-questions-on-draft-additional-protocol-concerning-the-protection-of-human-rights-and-dignity-of-persons-with-mental-disorder-with-reg

Unacceptable
The Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention is clashing with the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UN CRPD).

Human rights experts of the United Nations (UN) have explicitly called on members states to vote against this draft protocol, see: https://www.ohchr.org/en/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=27126&LangID=E

Also the Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe, Ms. Dunja Mijatovic, has repeatedly spoken out against the draft protocol, for example in 2018, see https://rm.coe.int/comments-by-dunja-mijatovic-council-of-europe-commissioner-for-human-r/16808f1111

The text of the draft protocol is only about procedures for deprivation of freedoms, including guidelines for the use of seclusion cells, restraining and even electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). These kind of practices have nothing to do with care, wellbeing or mental health. The approach under the draft protocol is old fashioned and outdated.

Care is attention. It is possible to prevent coercion, by preventing crises and escalations, by providing good support in line with human rights. A culture change is needed in mental health care, not only in the Netherlands, but in Europe as a whole.

Compendium
The ‘compendium on good practices’ to promote voluntary care and the prevention of coercion, which the Bioethics Committee of the Council of Europe has been composing by now, is misleading. It distracts the attention from the dangerous draft protocol, and it instills the suggestion of improvement of care, while the compendium also contains mediocre initiatives, is not binding at all, and there are no means being made available to actually implement these methods somewhere else or to develop them further into the human rights model. It is in fact just a paper list. In practice, the gaps in the care system are not solved and remain unaddressed. Instead of investing in actual support, they are investing in coercion and in procedures. That does not remedy the lack of support.

The draft protocol however will be binding if ratified by the member states of the Oviedo Convention. The deficiencies in support can then continue to exist, after which the law states that coercion remains ‘legitimate’, as long as one checks off enough procedures. These procedures are mandatory, yet good support apparently is not?

Average norm
The Council of Europe should hold the universal human rights in high esteem. But the regulation of the use of coercion in order to create more ‘unity’ between member states to a ‘average European norm’ is not the same as the actual realization of inclusion and human rights. The implementation of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities is for now still a challenge for every state, also for the so called ‘developed countries’.

Only good care should be regulated. Bad care should be prohibited.

The immense suffering that is hidden within the walls of the institutions cannot continue any longer. Already from the ‘90s onwards the principle was “the least possible coercion”, but annually the numbers on coercion are on the rise. The current system does not work, and ‘waiting until the problem solves itself’ is not an option. Active policy is needed to abolish coercion from health care immediately. The time of compromising has already passed, and now it is time for a real profound change.

Coercion in health care is not a solution, it is a problem.

What is needed, is more care, and not more coercion.

Committee of Ministers
On 2 November 2021 the Bioethics Committee of the Council of Europe has decided to send the draft protocol to the Committee of Ministers for decision making. It will probably be on their agenda in 2022.

It is very important that the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe votes against the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention. The minister who represents the Netherlands is the minister of Foreign Affairs, Ben Knapen.

Universal human rights
46 out of 47 member states of the Council of Europe have ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention would create conflicting standards in nearly all member states.

When an organization such as the Council of Europe would be able to nullify the effect of the universal human rights by means of a Protocol, then all other human rights are actually also on the line. We cannot let this happen.

It is crucial to vote against the draft protocol.

Call
Only together we can stop the draft protocol of the Council of Europe.

The draft protocol can be thrown out when enough ministers vote against the draft protocol in the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe.

It is therefore very important that also the Dutch minister of foreign affairs, Ben Knapen, shall vote against the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention.

The risk of wrong images about psychosocial disabilities is present at the Committee of Ministers, and therefore it is extra important to ensure good awareness raising on psychosocial disabilities, experiences with coercion in health care, alternative, experiences of recovery, failures of care and so on.

Everyone can help to raise awareness on this struggle for human rights in Europe, for example by carrying this message further and/or by making contact with the ministry of foreign affairs addressed to minister Ben Knapen.

It is time to stand up for human rights, in order to prevent the Council of Europe from making a big mistake.

Organize care instead of coercion.

More information
Would you like to know more about the actions and campaigns against the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention? The following websites give more information.

1. Call by UN-experts to vote against the protocol, see https://www.ohchr.org/en/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=27126&LangID=E

2. Campaign website of various European organisations against this protocol, see https://www.withdrawoviedo.info/join

3. Campaign materials of the European Network of Users, ex-users and Survivors of Psychiatry (ENUSP) active against this protocol, see
https://enusp.org/2018/05/29/draft-additional-protocol-to-the-oviedo-convention-related-materials/

4. Blog by Actiegroep Tekeer tegen de isoleer! / Stichting Mind Rights (Netherlands) with a report of the PACE hearing and a plea against the protocol, see
https://tekeertegendeisoleer.wordpress.com/2021/03/23/call-to-end-coercion-and-withdraw-draft-additional-protocol-to-the-oviedo-convention-pace-hearing/

5. Article in the European Times about the human rights problem at the Council of Europe, see
https://www.europeantimes.news/2021/11/the-human-rights-problem-of-the-council-of-europe/

6. Article by Human Rights Watch against this protocol, see
https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/11/04/what-does-council-europe-have-against-people-disabilities#

7. Blog by Actiegroep Tekeer tegen de isoleer! / Stichting Mind Rights (Netherlands) on why forced psychiatric treatment must be prohibited, see https://tekeertegendeisoleer.wordpress.com/2016/03/29/why-forced-psychiatric-treatment-must-be-prohibited/

Reageer op dit reisverslag

Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley

Jolijn

rondreizen en ontdekken hoe mensen met psychiatrische problemen overal (over)leven en kijken waarmee we elkaar kunnen helpen.

Actief sinds 21 Dec. 2006
Verslag gelezen: 5887
Totaal aantal bezoekers 719793

Voorgaande reizen:

05 Juni 2019 - 06 Juni 2019

Council of Europe - Bioethics Ctee 6 June 2019

12 Mei 2019 - 13 Mei 2019

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2019

08 Oktober 2018 - 10 Oktober 2018

Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit

20 Juni 2018 - 24 Juni 2018

Trieste congres June 2018

10 Juni 2018 - 15 Juni 2018

COSP CRPD 2018 New York

28 Mei 2018 - 29 Mei 2018

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2018

25 Mei 2018 - 28 Mei 2018

EDF General Assembly 2018 Vilnius

02 Maart 2018 - 04 Maart 2018

EDF Board meeting Brussels 2018

23 September 1994 - 16 Februari 2018

seeking access to justice in NL

05 Februari 2018 - 15 Februari 2018

5th Global Mental Health Summit, SA 2018

06 Oktober 2017 - 09 Oktober 2017

EDF Board meeting in Tallinn

11 Juni 2017 - 25 Juni 2017

COSP NY and Summerschool Galway

06 Juni 2017 - 07 Juni 2017

Council of Europe - Bioethics Committee meeting

18 Mei 2017 - 19 Mei 2017

European Commission Workforum on UN CRPD

11 Mei 2017 - 14 Mei 2017

EDF General Assembly 2017 Madrid

10 Maart 2017 - 14 Maart 2017

WHOCC conference on coercion - Paris 2017

17 Februari 2017 - 19 Februari 2017

EDF Board meeting 2017 Malta

24 November 2016 - 30 November 2016

INTAR India 2016

13 November 2016 - 16 November 2016

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar Berlin 2016

12 Oktober 2016 - 15 Oktober 2016

Expert meeting on the Right to Mental Health

26 September 2016 - 26 September 2016

Personal meeting with MEP Helga Stevens

14 September 2016 - 16 September 2016

5th European Conference on Mental Health

09 Augustus 2016 - 11 Augustus 2016

visit to Lister and ENIK Recovery College

22 Juni 2016 - 24 Juni 2016

NUI Galway Summer School Int. Disability Law

12 Juni 2016 - 18 Juni 2016

Conference of State Parties UN CRPD

09 Juni 2016 - 10 Juni 2016

EC Workforum on CRPD implementation

20 Mei 2016 - 22 Mei 2016

EDF Annual General Assembly 2016 in Dublin

17 Mei 2016 - 17 Mei 2016

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

09 April 2016 - 12 April 2016

WNUSP taskforce meeting and CRPD Committee

11 Maart 2016 - 13 Maart 2016

EDF board meeting Amsterdam 11-13 March 2016

13 December 2015 - 15 December 2015

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2015 Brussels

26 Oktober 2015 - 01 November 2015

Meetings in Brussels and Paris

26 Augustus 2015 - 29 Augustus 2015

EU review at 14th CRPD session in Geneva

15 Juli 2015 - 30 Juli 2015

Human rights work in Japan

01 Juni 2015 - 02 Juni 2015

EASPD Hearing at European Parliament

29 Mei 2015 - 31 Mei 2015

EDF General Assembly 2015 Warsaw

28 April 2015 - 29 April 2015

European Commission Work Forum CRPD implementation

29 Maart 2015 - 02 April 2015

UN CRPD Committee - 13th session

11 December 2014 - 14 December 2014

ENUSP General Assembly Hillerod 2014

14 Juli 2014 - 17 Juli 2014

Human Rights Committee 111 session July 2014

29 Maart 2014 - 05 April 2014

UN CRPD Committee sessions April 2014

09 Maart 2014 - 15 Maart 2014

HRC in Geneva and FGC in Zagreb

29 Januari 2014 - 01 Februari 2014

Empowerment Congress at WHO Europe CC

08 December 2013 - 11 December 2013

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2013 Bucharest

28 November 2013 - 01 December 2013

Starting FGC in Moldova - user/survivor initiative

29 Oktober 2013 - 02 November 2013

European Network for Family Group Conferencing

15 Juli 2013 - 20 Juli 2013

Conference of State Parties - New York 2013

12 Mei 2013 - 18 Mei 2013

CAT review of the Netherlands 2013

10 Maart 2013 - 15 Maart 2013

Rights into Action - training in Moldova

12 December 2012 - 16 December 2012

Expert meeting on torture- Washington DC

13 November 2012 - 14 November 2012

ENUSP MHE-Mapping Exclusion at European Parliament

05 November 2012 - 08 November 2012

London 5-8 November 2012

19 Oktober 2012 - 21 Oktober 2012

ENUSP Empowerment seminar in Zagreb

15 Juli 2012 - 28 Juli 2012

MDAC Summerschool 2012

12 Juni 2012 - 12 Juni 2012

ENUSP at EU Social Platform of NGO's

10 Mei 2012 - 11 Mei 2012

CAT session on Czech Republic - UN Geneva

14 December 2011 - 17 December 2011

OHCHR regional consultation on torture

11 Oktober 2011 - 01 November 2011

Zuid Afrika 2011

14 April 2010 - 18 April 2010

Praag - Building Bridges- Horatio

19 Oktober 2009 - 25 Oktober 2009

Congres in Stockholm

15 Maart 2009 - 30 Maart 2009

Oost Afrika 2009

29 Mei 2007 - 01 Juni 2007

WHO in Geneve, Zwitserland

03 Mei 2007 - 08 Mei 2007

Madrid - documentaire opnemen

07 Januari 2007 - 08 Februari 2007

Oost Afrika 2007

Landen bezocht: