Sad day, happy end - Reisverslag uit Kaapstad, Zuid-Afrika van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu Sad day, happy end - Reisverslag uit Kaapstad, Zuid-Afrika van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu

Sad day, happy end

Door: Jolijn

Blijf op de hoogte en volg Jolijn

27 Oktober 2011 | Zuid-Afrika, Kaapstad

I have been to Valkenberg psychiatric hospital, or should I say prison. It was bad. It was like a prison. They had more resources, but less care than Lentegeur. Oh my God, it was really sad what I saw. I will not write everything today, because I had some South African dube tonight, with Sally, who also knows the ins and outs about bad treatments, just like me. We had a good survivor-girls-evening with the three of us, Annie, Sally and me. That was the happy end. That was really nice, but Valkenberg bleeehhh..
The admission ward was really looking like a prison ward, patients behind real bars, staff in the middle in a glass island.. the first things users in the male admission ward said was: This place is like a prison.. I really felt sad after seeing the institution. I wasn’t allowed to make any photographs at all, but I saw a lot. I went to male-admission ward (high care unit..pfff prison.. - “dear patient, comply here to get out” - ..), female closed sub-acute ward, hmmmzz, patients were “too ill” for everything, and by making progress to this ward they were visually moving towards the gate, .. - “earn your freedom, Be Healthy” - And I saw the forensic ward..pff strict and poorly equipped.. the youngest patients was 17, “he may look sweet but he’s a gangster and has killed a girl, while the other raped her”.. and this young boy is now stuck with 30 adults in this hopeless prison ward.. - “What perspective?” -

It had nothing to do with care, and certainly not mental health care. It was really like a prison, but it looked very nice on the outside, apart from the double fences, and the admission-ward was only 5 years old, no doors, just real bars.
They wanted to rebuild the place, “because some parts were old, and the nice compounds with palm trees dated from the 1980s, when the Christian view said you needed space, but now they want something more compact, with everything closer to each other”, which clearly means: more like a prison-hospital with a medical view, drilling the people to behave..
And they did have wooden chairs and coloured table cloths on the female ward, and there was some coloured painted art they made, and a few buckets of flowers in the yard, so they actually sometimes had things.. but the view of the carers was quite horrible.
Although I liked the one who led me around. She was nice, she actually told at every ward that I was a consultant for psychiatry in the Netherlands, and I was interested in treatments with force, and they actually let me in everywhere, and so I got a lot of info. She didn’t say I was from a user movement, which she knew. She really got me in. And she saw some things herself, she wasn’t stupid, but in the sound of her voice I heard the hopelessness, that change won’t come here.. It was sad. It felt like a bad place.

Valkenberg is originally a “white-built psychiatric hospital”, with beautiful compounds, with palm trees, green grass and some monumental buildings, (and their view is also monu-mental instead of environ-mental). They did have some more resources, but less care.. Fear dominated, and they had obviously a kind of European / American view of medicalizing care, like the illness has to be captured and drugged away..

I’m really ashamed to be European, and Dutch.. to be of one of those countries who colonized here (and psychiatry still does). It’s my country and others who feed Africa with this crap of psychiatry.. with the medical view.. It’s so obvious that psychosis and so come from uncoped relationship issues and trauma so on, it IS a social issue.. I’m really happy that Lentegeur is also here in the district, and that patients tell each other where to go. Nobody likes Valkenberg, and Lentegeur is said to be better. (not perfect, but nowhere is, we can only find the best practices).

In my opinion, they should break Valkenberg down, and certainly NOT give them money for a rebuild, they are abusing their resources. Even if I could choose, I’d rather be at Lentegeur, than at Valkenberg. Especially when you talk to people, you can feel the vibe.. Valkenberg is strict, really prison-like, except for that the patients get drugged as well (and in prison they don’t). And Valkenberg doesn’t feel for the social model, although they call their admission “High Care” (but it looks like a prison, and there is no way to ignore that, there is no way to provide humane care there), and they had an ACT team there, but what I heard this was more like a medication-supervision team, and if you don’t comply with your treatment, they will give forced medication, outside the institution, but then you will still have your freedom of movement…

This is not human-right compliant. It doesn’t show compassion, you cannot force commitment. And they totally didn’t see it. You could feel how strict everything was, even for the nurses, they knew nothing would actually change, even ordering soap or pillows leads to a struggle in the organization. They were basically burn-out.

Afterwards, I walked along the fence, digesting what I just saw, looking at the little river and the flowers (springtime!) and then I took a train home. My head was full.

Then Annie and I drove to Muizenberg, to see the sea, the ocean. We saw a lot of surfers there. And I wished I could surf as well, missing my blades and the smooth slides, I would have loved to dive in the water, but it was getting cold and I had no wetsuit or so. Then we ate something and drove off to Sally, to pick her up and go to the local bar.

We had a lot of fun being at the bar. We ate a pizza and went to Sally’s home. And I smoked some dube, and we had a very long and honest talk about seclusion experiences and so on. It was really painful, but also very good to share this with each other. We all had our horrors in psychiatry. We are survivors. And we really laughed about a lot of things, how crazy THEY are. Yeah, it was good to do so. The evening was nice. Tomorrow we will go out as well, to dance. I’m a free tourist now, I can do whatever I like, no more appointments, no more witnessing violations (except Robben Island, if they stop their strike… ). I can relax now, and enjoy. And if the strike continues at Robben Island, I will make sure that I will see whales and dolphins, as a compensation (sometimes you see them on the ferry to Robben Island, and I already liked that idea). I love the ocean. That’s for sure. Today I printed my footprints in the sand of the beach.. love it! I will make sure that I will enjoy myself the next few days.

  • 28 Oktober 2011 - 07:21

    Je Moeder:

    Kop op meid!
    Je doet prima werk; maar nu nog een paar dagen relaxen.
    Geniet!!
    Liefs,

  • 28 Oktober 2011 - 14:14

    Tony:

    Have a nice weekend! See you soon :)

  • 22 Januari 2013 - 15:52

    Marlize Swanepoel:

    Hello,

    I have been reading your blogs on Valkenberg and Lentegeur with great interest - thanks! I'm a Dramatherapist who recently returned to South Africa (Cape Town) and am looking for ways to start some groups in the above-mentioned hospitals. In London, I ran Dramatherapy groups in psychiatric hospitals. As you said, the issue of funding in SA may be tricky, but I hope to find a way. The service users certainly can do with some therapeutic input and the arts is such a great way for supporting people through their hospital stay.

    I've also been to Valkenberg, but never went inside - I was shocked to read your experience. I look forward to contacting Lentegeur; please let me know if you have any suggestions or tips for setting up an arts therapy service there.

    Take care,

    Marlize

Reageer op dit reisverslag

Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley

Jolijn

rondreizen en ontdekken hoe mensen met psychiatrische problemen overal (over)leven en kijken waarmee we elkaar kunnen helpen.

Actief sinds 21 Dec. 2006
Verslag gelezen: 1202
Totaal aantal bezoekers 781830

Voorgaande reizen:

05 Juni 2019 - 06 Juni 2019

Council of Europe - Bioethics Ctee 6 June 2019

12 Mei 2019 - 13 Mei 2019

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2019

08 Oktober 2018 - 10 Oktober 2018

Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit

20 Juni 2018 - 24 Juni 2018

Trieste congres June 2018

10 Juni 2018 - 15 Juni 2018

COSP CRPD 2018 New York

28 Mei 2018 - 29 Mei 2018

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2018

25 Mei 2018 - 28 Mei 2018

EDF General Assembly 2018 Vilnius

02 Maart 2018 - 04 Maart 2018

EDF Board meeting Brussels 2018

23 September 1994 - 16 Februari 2018

seeking access to justice in NL

05 Februari 2018 - 15 Februari 2018

5th Global Mental Health Summit, SA 2018

06 Oktober 2017 - 09 Oktober 2017

EDF Board meeting in Tallinn

11 Juni 2017 - 25 Juni 2017

COSP NY and Summerschool Galway

06 Juni 2017 - 07 Juni 2017

Council of Europe - Bioethics Committee meeting

18 Mei 2017 - 19 Mei 2017

European Commission Workforum on UN CRPD

11 Mei 2017 - 14 Mei 2017

EDF General Assembly 2017 Madrid

10 Maart 2017 - 14 Maart 2017

WHOCC conference on coercion - Paris 2017

17 Februari 2017 - 19 Februari 2017

EDF Board meeting 2017 Malta

24 November 2016 - 30 November 2016

INTAR India 2016

13 November 2016 - 16 November 2016

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar Berlin 2016

12 Oktober 2016 - 15 Oktober 2016

Expert meeting on the Right to Mental Health

26 September 2016 - 26 September 2016

Personal meeting with MEP Helga Stevens

14 September 2016 - 16 September 2016

5th European Conference on Mental Health

09 Augustus 2016 - 11 Augustus 2016

visit to Lister and ENIK Recovery College

22 Juni 2016 - 24 Juni 2016

NUI Galway Summer School Int. Disability Law

12 Juni 2016 - 18 Juni 2016

Conference of State Parties UN CRPD

09 Juni 2016 - 10 Juni 2016

EC Workforum on CRPD implementation

20 Mei 2016 - 22 Mei 2016

EDF Annual General Assembly 2016 in Dublin

17 Mei 2016 - 17 Mei 2016

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

09 April 2016 - 12 April 2016

WNUSP taskforce meeting and CRPD Committee

11 Maart 2016 - 13 Maart 2016

EDF board meeting Amsterdam 11-13 March 2016

13 December 2015 - 15 December 2015

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2015 Brussels

26 Oktober 2015 - 01 November 2015

Meetings in Brussels and Paris

26 Augustus 2015 - 29 Augustus 2015

EU review at 14th CRPD session in Geneva

15 Juli 2015 - 30 Juli 2015

Human rights work in Japan

01 Juni 2015 - 02 Juni 2015

EASPD Hearing at European Parliament

29 Mei 2015 - 31 Mei 2015

EDF General Assembly 2015 Warsaw

28 April 2015 - 29 April 2015

European Commission Work Forum CRPD implementation

29 Maart 2015 - 02 April 2015

UN CRPD Committee - 13th session

11 December 2014 - 14 December 2014

ENUSP General Assembly Hillerod 2014

14 Juli 2014 - 17 Juli 2014

Human Rights Committee 111 session July 2014

29 Maart 2014 - 05 April 2014

UN CRPD Committee sessions April 2014

09 Maart 2014 - 15 Maart 2014

HRC in Geneva and FGC in Zagreb

29 Januari 2014 - 01 Februari 2014

Empowerment Congress at WHO Europe CC

08 December 2013 - 11 December 2013

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2013 Bucharest

28 November 2013 - 01 December 2013

Starting FGC in Moldova - user/survivor initiative

29 Oktober 2013 - 02 November 2013

European Network for Family Group Conferencing

15 Juli 2013 - 20 Juli 2013

Conference of State Parties - New York 2013

12 Mei 2013 - 18 Mei 2013

CAT review of the Netherlands 2013

10 Maart 2013 - 15 Maart 2013

Rights into Action - training in Moldova

12 December 2012 - 16 December 2012

Expert meeting on torture- Washington DC

13 November 2012 - 14 November 2012

ENUSP MHE-Mapping Exclusion at European Parliament

05 November 2012 - 08 November 2012

London 5-8 November 2012

19 Oktober 2012 - 21 Oktober 2012

ENUSP Empowerment seminar in Zagreb

15 Juli 2012 - 28 Juli 2012

MDAC Summerschool 2012

12 Juni 2012 - 12 Juni 2012

ENUSP at EU Social Platform of NGO's

10 Mei 2012 - 11 Mei 2012

CAT session on Czech Republic - UN Geneva

14 December 2011 - 17 December 2011

OHCHR regional consultation on torture

11 Oktober 2011 - 01 November 2011

Zuid Afrika 2011

14 April 2010 - 18 April 2010

Praag - Building Bridges- Horatio

19 Oktober 2009 - 25 Oktober 2009

Congres in Stockholm

15 Maart 2009 - 30 Maart 2009

Oost Afrika 2009

29 Mei 2007 - 01 Juni 2007

WHO in Geneve, Zwitserland

03 Mei 2007 - 08 Mei 2007

Madrid - documentaire opnemen

07 Januari 2007 - 08 Februari 2007

Oost Afrika 2007

Landen bezocht: