Visit to psychiatric hospital Chisinau Moldova - Reisverslag uit Chisinau, Moldavië van Jolijn Santegoeds - Visit to psychiatric hospital Chisinau Moldova - Reisverslag uit Chisinau, Moldavië van Jolijn Santegoeds -

Visit to psychiatric hospital Chisinau Moldova

Door: Jolijn

Blijf op de hoogte en volg Jolijn

15 Maart 2013 | Moldavië, Chisinau

Today, 14 March 2013, we had the site visit to the psychiatric hospital in Chisinau, Moldova. At 8.30 we gathered in front of Le Roi Business Centre (the training venue) and a minibus came to pick us up. We went with 14 people who formed 2 groups, and I would lead one of the groups. It was the first time that I would lead a monitoring-training-team on site, and I was a little bit nervous/excited for what was to come. I knew that besides dealing with my own impressions, I would also have to be a leader, taking care of the group’s process. That made it extra special, and different from other visits to painful places.

We drove for about 45 minutes before arriving at the psychiatric hospital compounds. The hospital was founded in 1895, and there were many old buildings, some were abandoned and falling apart. The sight of that immediately raised a feeling of neglect and social unimportance. Some old buildings were in use, and also some newer buildings were placed in between. This resulted in a quite messy mix of buildings in a huge park-like area, with a rather long entrance road.

When we arrived we first had a chat with the deputy-director. The administration building wasn’t accessible for wheelchairs, so we went off to the only wheelchair-accessible building: General Psychiatry, to have a chat in the hall.
Basically we let the monitor-trainees ask the questions, and Oliver gave some extra coaching and tips. Then we split up in groups to do an actual monitoring visit (observing and interviewing).

At the third floor there were 2 psychiatric wards: one for males and one for females. My group went to the female ward. I had an interpreter on my side to be able to follow what was said. The members of my group split up further and started interviewing staff and patients. I also took a look around and talked to some persons, while “monitoring the monitor-trainees”. I felt quite responsible, but it appeared that I didn’t have to steer them in their contact-skills, so I just made sure that they could talk in private to the persons they wanted to talk to, and I talked a lot to staff, who seemed quite happy to be heard in their complaints on understaffing and lowered wages and so on. Because I was a kind of facilitator for the group, I couldn’t put my own interests or curiosity on the front, but I went from room to room, touching on every pair of monitor-trainees to check if everything was going fine. It all went well. On both wards that we visited (also the male ward on the fourth floor).

But of course, like any psychiatric institution, it was a painful place. It was actually horrible. There were 60 persons packed in 8 to 10 rooms. The rooms were filled with beds and mainly empty bedside-tables side by side. Most of the persons were in pyamas and laying in bed, severely drugged. There was this typical, disgusting smell of unwashed people in an unventilated ward. Water was cut off for so-called “safety-reasons”, and so was the electricity. The persons got to shower only once a week, in a group shower for 3 persons, which is obviously very degrading. Also the toilet was a set of 3 pots in one room, without any privacy.

The rooms seemed to correspond with a kind of step-programme: the rooms closest to the guard’s office were the rooms for admission and “surveillance” (regime 1.1). The nurse explained: “This is the room for agitated persons” : what we saw was 10 zombified persons laying in their beds… It appeared that the treatment for any mental problem is: knock-out by Haloperidol or Aminazine and laying in bed, just as in the 70s in the Netherlands. Then as a next step (next room, regime 2.1), persons were allowed to walk on the corridor of the ward with supervision of a nurse, sister or carer. The next step (regime 2.2.a) is that they are allowed to walk on the ward on their own, and (2.2.b) go to the caged balcony and go with family (without nurse-supervision). In step 3 and 4.a the persons are allowed to walk out on their own.
This appears to be the regime on all wards (except on the second floor the regime was like a general hospital, for ‘neurological illness’ which were milder, such as depressions). So treatment for any mental problem comprises getting medication and walking around.

There is not any social activity or whatsoever. There is no choice at all, and the administration of medication is often accompanied with force and full repression, including violence and physical abuse.

The place was really unbearable. Many persons told us they wanted out, and one lady was actually climbing on her bed to reach to the barred and locked window, but she was pulled down by the nurse, who was typically dressed in a white dress. Generally 99% of staff were female (only on the male ward there was 1 male corridor-guard). People asked us many things: such as cigarettes, make-up, when they would get out or see their family. It was totally heartbreaking to see people so fully deprived of everything in life, even deprived of having their own feelings - their identity is taken away by being so drugged. They are made totally voiceless, and are treated as objects without a soul. It is so utterly dehumanizing and I had to fight my tears.

The only ‘positive’ was that Moldovan system only arranges for stays of 30-60 days. So the persons might get out of there at some point (as long as they are not immediately returned by the often unwilling community). So they generally aren’t there for years - except in the wards for Forced Treatment, which are the forensic ward with court orders (of which the name suggests that all non-forensic treatments are “voluntary treatment” , but we know better… The signatures for “consent” are forced or done by the guardian, which can be the institution itself).

The entire group was moved by what we had seen in the psychiatric hospital. For some it was the first experience of visiting such a psychiatric institution. But they all learned a lot and they were grateful for getting this opportunity.

It was really great that after half a day, around noon, one member of the NPM showed up at the visit, and also the independent Ombuds-women who is specialized in psychiatry issues joined later. This really made me feel good, like there is hope on building bridges. And maybe my theory of yesterday was wrong. The NPM appeared to be volunteers, who also have another job, which may also be a reason why members weren’t participating in our training. The psychiatric-Ombudswomen is dedicated, but is rather excluded by the rest of the monitoring mechanisms, which puts her in a very hard position.

After the visit, around 14.30 we went back to Le Roi Business Centre, where we had a late lunch in the side-room of the conference-room, which was occupied by another group. We had to be quiet not to disturb the other conference, and everyone was so hungry that we ate our delivered meals in a comfortable silence. At 4 we could use the conference-room for ourselves, and we resumed the training by debriefing the visit, which we will continue to do tomorrow.

What we have seen today was disturbing and terrible. Nobody should have to live like that. Initially for me it was again quite hard and confusing to digest what I had seen, and to relate these experiences to my own experiences. Moldovan psychiatry is so clearly wrong and ill-treatment/torture. In the Netherlands it looks nice and it’s less clear that it’s a violation. It’s hard to say what’s worse: 2 months in full horror, or 2 years in ‘soft-horror’... But after all, there is no need to rank violations. BAD IS BAD, and it should be GOOD.

It’s our duty as human beings to care for another. The horrible deprivations must be stopped, and we should make it right. The devastation of human lives cannot be ignored any longer.

And after all, I find it a pity that I can’t give any substantial training to the staff of the hospital. It’s a missed opportunity, because I do think I could have brought some awareness and ideas. But as a monitoring-body, you have to be neutral. And I was a facilitator/ monitoring coach. But somehow that feels unsatisfying. I would have rather tried to improve things right away, in close communication with the staff, instead of just “noticing” what’s wrong and bringing that out. So I guess I’m not really a monitoring-type, or it should be extended with an intensive feedback-session to the hospital, in order to empower them with alternative ideas. I think it’s a missed opportunity to leave out mediation and collaboration on improvement. Pointing fingers may not result in an understanding of good practices, but rather create distance and more closed doors. I personally think that education of the staff and policy makers may be more effective to bring an actual positive change. I will surely mention this tomorrow at the evaluation.

It was an intense day, but I’m satisfied with the training we did. The skills we learned are useful to identify shortcomings, but I think we should also build bridges to the institution, in order to guide them to quality of care, and not just try to impose High Profile-demands with UN stuff, NPM’s and public reports.
Anyway, I’m done for today. I have offloaded my emotional baggage from the visit in several ways now, and I’m going to sleep. Tomorrow will be the last day of our training here. It was an intense week.

  • 15 Maart 2013 - 16:55


    een interessant verslag Jolijn.
    Fijn dat je morgen weer thuis komt! Je hebt weer goed werk verricht!
    je moeder

  • 08 Oktober 2016 - 22:11


    hello, please send me a mail. i have some questions! please!

Reageer op dit reisverslag

Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley


rondreizen en ontdekken hoe mensen met psychiatrische problemen overal (over)leven en kijken waarmee we elkaar kunnen helpen.

Actief sinds 21 Dec. 2006
Verslag gelezen: 2784
Totaal aantal bezoekers 695121

Voorgaande reizen:

05 Juni 2019 - 06 Juni 2019

Council of Europe - Bioethics Ctee 6 June 2019

12 Mei 2019 - 13 Mei 2019

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2019

08 Oktober 2018 - 10 Oktober 2018

Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit

20 Juni 2018 - 24 Juni 2018

Trieste congres June 2018

10 Juni 2018 - 15 Juni 2018

COSP CRPD 2018 New York

28 Mei 2018 - 29 Mei 2018

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2018

25 Mei 2018 - 28 Mei 2018

EDF General Assembly 2018 Vilnius

02 Maart 2018 - 04 Maart 2018

EDF Board meeting Brussels 2018

23 September 1994 - 16 Februari 2018

seeking access to justice in NL

05 Februari 2018 - 15 Februari 2018

5th Global Mental Health Summit, SA 2018

06 Oktober 2017 - 09 Oktober 2017

EDF Board meeting in Tallinn

11 Juni 2017 - 25 Juni 2017

COSP NY and Summerschool Galway

06 Juni 2017 - 07 Juni 2017

Council of Europe - Bioethics Committee meeting

18 Mei 2017 - 19 Mei 2017

European Commission Workforum on UN CRPD

11 Mei 2017 - 14 Mei 2017

EDF General Assembly 2017 Madrid

10 Maart 2017 - 14 Maart 2017

WHOCC conference on coercion - Paris 2017

17 Februari 2017 - 19 Februari 2017

EDF Board meeting 2017 Malta

24 November 2016 - 30 November 2016

INTAR India 2016

13 November 2016 - 16 November 2016

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar Berlin 2016

12 Oktober 2016 - 15 Oktober 2016

Expert meeting on the Right to Mental Health

26 September 2016 - 26 September 2016

Personal meeting with MEP Helga Stevens

14 September 2016 - 16 September 2016

5th European Conference on Mental Health

09 Augustus 2016 - 11 Augustus 2016

visit to Lister and ENIK Recovery College

22 Juni 2016 - 24 Juni 2016

NUI Galway Summer School Int. Disability Law

12 Juni 2016 - 18 Juni 2016

Conference of State Parties UN CRPD

09 Juni 2016 - 10 Juni 2016

EC Workforum on CRPD implementation

20 Mei 2016 - 22 Mei 2016

EDF Annual General Assembly 2016 in Dublin

17 Mei 2016 - 17 Mei 2016

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

09 April 2016 - 12 April 2016

WNUSP taskforce meeting and CRPD Committee

11 Maart 2016 - 13 Maart 2016

EDF board meeting Amsterdam 11-13 March 2016

13 December 2015 - 15 December 2015

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2015 Brussels

26 Oktober 2015 - 01 November 2015

Meetings in Brussels and Paris

26 Augustus 2015 - 29 Augustus 2015

EU review at 14th CRPD session in Geneva

15 Juli 2015 - 30 Juli 2015

Human rights work in Japan

01 Juni 2015 - 02 Juni 2015

EASPD Hearing at European Parliament

29 Mei 2015 - 31 Mei 2015

EDF General Assembly 2015 Warsaw

28 April 2015 - 29 April 2015

European Commission Work Forum CRPD implementation

29 Maart 2015 - 02 April 2015

UN CRPD Committee - 13th session

11 December 2014 - 14 December 2014

ENUSP General Assembly Hillerod 2014

14 Juli 2014 - 17 Juli 2014

Human Rights Committee 111 session July 2014

29 Maart 2014 - 05 April 2014

UN CRPD Committee sessions April 2014

09 Maart 2014 - 15 Maart 2014

HRC in Geneva and FGC in Zagreb

29 Januari 2014 - 01 Februari 2014

Empowerment Congress at WHO Europe CC

08 December 2013 - 11 December 2013

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2013 Bucharest

28 November 2013 - 01 December 2013

Starting FGC in Moldova - user/survivor initiative

29 Oktober 2013 - 02 November 2013

European Network for Family Group Conferencing

15 Juli 2013 - 20 Juli 2013

Conference of State Parties - New York 2013

12 Mei 2013 - 18 Mei 2013

CAT review of the Netherlands 2013

10 Maart 2013 - 15 Maart 2013

Rights into Action - training in Moldova

12 December 2012 - 16 December 2012

Expert meeting on torture- Washington DC

13 November 2012 - 14 November 2012

ENUSP MHE-Mapping Exclusion at European Parliament

05 November 2012 - 08 November 2012

London 5-8 November 2012

19 Oktober 2012 - 21 Oktober 2012

ENUSP Empowerment seminar in Zagreb

15 Juli 2012 - 28 Juli 2012

MDAC Summerschool 2012

12 Juni 2012 - 12 Juni 2012

ENUSP at EU Social Platform of NGO's

10 Mei 2012 - 11 Mei 2012

CAT session on Czech Republic - UN Geneva

14 December 2011 - 17 December 2011

OHCHR regional consultation on torture

11 Oktober 2011 - 01 November 2011

Zuid Afrika 2011

14 April 2010 - 18 April 2010

Praag - Building Bridges- Horatio

19 Oktober 2009 - 25 Oktober 2009

Congres in Stockholm

15 Maart 2009 - 30 Maart 2009

Oost Afrika 2009

29 Mei 2007 - 01 Juni 2007

WHO in Geneve, Zwitserland

03 Mei 2007 - 08 Mei 2007

Madrid - documentaire opnemen

07 Januari 2007 - 08 Februari 2007

Oost Afrika 2007

Landen bezocht: