2 meetings in Brussels - Reisverslag uit Brussel, België van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu 2 meetings in Brussels - Reisverslag uit Brussel, België van Jolijn Santegoeds - WaarBenJij.nu

2 meetings in Brussels

Door: Jolijn

Blijf op de hoogte en volg Jolijn

27 Oktober 2015 | België, Brussel

1. EC Follow up on CRPD Concluding Observations

Yesterday, Monday 26 October 2015, I travelled to Brussels for an afternoon meeting with the European Commission DG Employment, for an informal discussion on the follow up to the recommendations of the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities that were issued to the EU in September 2015 (UN CRPD Concluding Observations on the EU).

I arrived in Brussels with a delay of over 1 hour, due to a broken train on the track. Therefor I missed the first hour of the meeting and I sneaked in around 3 PM. There were about 20 people in the room, and most of them I already knew as representatives of European NGOs/DPOs. They were sharing their opinions and ideas on what needs to be done to implement the recommendations of the UN CRPD Committee at EU level. I listened to the dialogue, and waited for my turn. It was quite interesting to hear the suggestions for EU action by the various organizations. It’s a really a pity that I missed the start, so I don’t have a full overview.
The delegation of the European Commission’s DG on Employment was not able to give a substantial reply right away, because they need to discuss it within the European Commission first. There is nothing decided yet regarding follow-up actions. In response to the ideas of civil society, the EC-delegation repeatedly said they “took note of it” and that they “will discuss it with the various bodies in the European Commission”. I felt like nothing had changed since the UN recommendations had come out, and I feared that the European mechanisms would keep on claiming that they lack power/competence on our issues, and they “will see what they can do about it within the margins”. As if the European Union is powerless, and as if we should be satisfied with marginal attention, while so many persons with psychosocial disabilities in the EU are suffering from a wide range of human rights violations. That frankly upset me, so when it was my turn to speak, I made a firm intervention:

I explained that, so far, none of the European Member States have restored the right to liberty of persons with psychosocial disabilities on an equal basis with others. And none of the European Member States have abolished substitute decision-making, and none have banned forced psychiatric interventions by law. Instead, the European countries maintain laws, or create new laws, authorizing these practises, and so far, the European Union shows no resistance to these law reforms contrary to the CRPD by its Member States. Additionally, the EU shows also no resistance to international laws which allow for forced psychiatric interventions, such as the European Convention on Human Rights. Instead of resistance, the EU actually promotes these standards, since ratification of the European Convention on Human Rights still is a condition for EU-membership, and there is not even any declaration or statement of the EU to nullify article 5. And in practice, the existence of these discriminatory domestic and international laws prevents us, persons with psychosocial disabilities, from accessing justice, since the forced psychiatric interventions are allowed under these laws and these practices are therefore not regarded as violations, while it is actually torture and ill-treatment. So altogether, in practice we have no rights and no access to justice. And I can tell you from my personal perspective that the lack of access to justice is a very heavy burden. As an illustration: I was long term solitary confined as a child, in the Netherlands (a country that most consider as ‘very nice’) , and now I am trying for about 20 years to get access to justice, I tried even at Ombudsman and Ministry and at UN level etcetera, but I still haven’t succeeded, not even an investigation. This hurts so much. It is really a burden. This kind of practices need to change. We want our rights. So why is the EU not taking action against the widespread human rights violation on persons with psychosocial disabilities in the EU? Why no action against forced interventions, against domestic and international laws that allow torturous practices, against the lack of access to justice?
It seems that the EU constantly claims they have no authority over our main issues, such as liberty, freedom, justice, legal capacity or quality of care in EUs Member States, and they claim that they “cannot” take actions against forced psychiatric practices and the widespread related injustices and human right violations inside the EU. And even despite the UN CRPD Committee recommendations, which clearly recommend to the EU that they should ‘take all possible actions to ensure liberty and security of all persons with all types of disabilities in line with the Guidelines on article 14’ , and despite the fact that the EU claims to be funded on the core values as ‘respect to human rights, freedom, equality and justice’, they still claim they cannot act against discriminatory deprivation of liberty and this type of injustices in Member States, leaving many thousands of EU citizens unprotected for the sake of European own-made system of agreements. It looks like the EU finds bureaucratic agreements more important than our human rights? This is simply not acceptable. Action is needed. Real change is needed. The EU should take leadership, and the competences should be reconsidered in order to protect the rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities. The CRPD clearly calls for change, and we really want to see change. EUs ratification of the CRPD should also have meaning for us, persons with psychosocial disabilities, otherwise there is no real hope for us in this European process.”

After my intervention, there was a bit of a silence. (probably due the intensity of my plea, and possibly because I approached the subject out of the box). Then Ms. Cabral, head of the EC-unit for the rights of persons with disabilities, responded by reaffirming their good intentions to see what they can do about it, and she acknowledged that these were important issues, and then she added “but maybe not everything can be solved at EU level”.

I immediately raised my hand and stated: it is unacceptable that the EU uses bureaucratic excuses (such as “lack of power”) instead of acting against torture and ill-treatment by forced psychiatry in Member States. Bureaucracy is not a valid argument to allow torture. Torture and ill-treatment are absolutely prohibited and there can be no excuse at all. It just needs to stop and action is needed.
I then asked to her directly: Is there any hope for us in this process? Or is the energy and input in vain because of the lack of competences?
She said there is hope.

And then the meeting ended. It had been quite intense for me. I got some compliments on my intervention from other participants, and Annalisa Cottone from the European Commission’s unit for the rights of persons with disabilities proposed to have a talk about these issues on Thursday 29 October, when I will meet her again at a conference on CRPD article 12 in Paris. That is great. It gives me hope again.

After the meeting, I went along with some others (MDAC and Autism Europe) to have a drink in a bar, and then we dropped off our bags at the various hotels, and walked around in the centre of Brussels together, checking the chocolate stores, and having a belated but nice Belgian dinner with mussels and fries. I really enjoyed the evening, and I returned to my hotel a little bit late, so I decided to postpone blogging, since I would have more time the next day, and I was tired. So I went to sleep.

2. Discussing the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention at OHCHR Europe

The next day (today), Tuesday 27 October 2015, I had another afternoon meeting in Brussels, at 14.30 at the UN OHCHR regional office for Europe, to discuss a strategic response to the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (made by Council of Europe). It was a small informal meeting of just over an hour with Jan Jarab and 3 staff from the OHCHR Regional Office for Europe, Oliver Lewis (MDAC) on the phone, and Alva Finn (MHE) and me (ENUSP) in person. We discussed how to approach the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention, and we decided that we will aim to prevent the adoption of this Additional Protocol, since it won’t bring any benefit for any party at all. So each organization will respond to the public consultation that is launched by the Council of Europe on the Draft Additional Protocol to the Oviedo Convention (see http://www.coe.int/en/web/bioethics/-/public-consultation-on-a-working-document?redirect=http://www.coe.int/en/web/bioethics/psychiatry?p_p_id=101_INSTANCE_mUCQzOkGjpPx&p_p_lifecycle=0&p_p_state=normal&p_p_mode=view&p_p_col_id=column-4&p_p_col_pos=1&p_p_col_count=2 ) And we will also work on a joint statement, which all needs to be done before 15 November 2015. It was a pleasant and constructive meeting, with a nice harmony of opinions, and an inspiring level of ambition. Real goals, real hope and real actions. That is inspiring. I can’t help to notice the difference with yesterday’s meeting on the EU trajectory of CRPD implementation, which excels in the absence of any real ambitions on the rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities (which is something that really causes me to doubt whether I should put my energy there at all, since we need REAL change).

Anyway, after this meeting, I walked around a bit more, again searching for a place with wifi where I could work. Then eventually I needed a power-socket, and I decided to go to the train station quite early, where I charged my laptop with my own renewable energy (cycling on a machine to generate power – although it didn’t really work, it was nice to be a bit active). Then I took the Thalys train to Paris Nord (with a power socket on board) and there Stephanie, my colleague in ENUSP, picked me up and we spend the evening together, driving past the main touristic attractions such as Notre Dame, Louvre, Opera, and the Eiffel Tower exactly on the moment that it started sparkling lights!, and we had a delicious typical French meal at Ile Saint-Louis, with absolutely delicious ice cream (Halloween flavour and Raspberry with rose) and talking about all kinds of things. I really enjoyed this great evening with Stephanie in Paris. It was already late when Stephanie left me at the hotel, but I still decided to finish this blog before going to sleep, because tomorrow a new conference starts, and I don’t want my head to get too full. So it’s offloaded now, and now I am ready for the next part of this week. Good night!

Reageer op dit reisverslag

Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley


rondreizen en ontdekken hoe mensen met psychiatrische problemen overal (over)leven en kijken waarmee we elkaar kunnen helpen.

Actief sinds 21 Dec. 2006
Verslag gelezen: 784
Totaal aantal bezoekers 695121

Voorgaande reizen:

05 Juni 2019 - 06 Juni 2019

Council of Europe - Bioethics Ctee 6 June 2019

12 Mei 2019 - 13 Mei 2019

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2019

08 Oktober 2018 - 10 Oktober 2018

Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit

20 Juni 2018 - 24 Juni 2018

Trieste congres June 2018

10 Juni 2018 - 15 Juni 2018

COSP CRPD 2018 New York

28 Mei 2018 - 29 Mei 2018

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2018

25 Mei 2018 - 28 Mei 2018

EDF General Assembly 2018 Vilnius

02 Maart 2018 - 04 Maart 2018

EDF Board meeting Brussels 2018

23 September 1994 - 16 Februari 2018

seeking access to justice in NL

05 Februari 2018 - 15 Februari 2018

5th Global Mental Health Summit, SA 2018

06 Oktober 2017 - 09 Oktober 2017

EDF Board meeting in Tallinn

11 Juni 2017 - 25 Juni 2017

COSP NY and Summerschool Galway

06 Juni 2017 - 07 Juni 2017

Council of Europe - Bioethics Committee meeting

18 Mei 2017 - 19 Mei 2017

European Commission Workforum on UN CRPD

11 Mei 2017 - 14 Mei 2017

EDF General Assembly 2017 Madrid

10 Maart 2017 - 14 Maart 2017

WHOCC conference on coercion - Paris 2017

17 Februari 2017 - 19 Februari 2017

EDF Board meeting 2017 Malta

24 November 2016 - 30 November 2016

INTAR India 2016

13 November 2016 - 16 November 2016

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar Berlin 2016

12 Oktober 2016 - 15 Oktober 2016

Expert meeting on the Right to Mental Health

26 September 2016 - 26 September 2016

Personal meeting with MEP Helga Stevens

14 September 2016 - 16 September 2016

5th European Conference on Mental Health

09 Augustus 2016 - 11 Augustus 2016

visit to Lister and ENIK Recovery College

22 Juni 2016 - 24 Juni 2016

NUI Galway Summer School Int. Disability Law

12 Juni 2016 - 18 Juni 2016

Conference of State Parties UN CRPD

09 Juni 2016 - 10 Juni 2016

EC Workforum on CRPD implementation

20 Mei 2016 - 22 Mei 2016

EDF Annual General Assembly 2016 in Dublin

17 Mei 2016 - 17 Mei 2016

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

09 April 2016 - 12 April 2016

WNUSP taskforce meeting and CRPD Committee

11 Maart 2016 - 13 Maart 2016

EDF board meeting Amsterdam 11-13 March 2016

13 December 2015 - 15 December 2015

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2015 Brussels

26 Oktober 2015 - 01 November 2015

Meetings in Brussels and Paris

26 Augustus 2015 - 29 Augustus 2015

EU review at 14th CRPD session in Geneva

15 Juli 2015 - 30 Juli 2015

Human rights work in Japan

01 Juni 2015 - 02 Juni 2015

EASPD Hearing at European Parliament

29 Mei 2015 - 31 Mei 2015

EDF General Assembly 2015 Warsaw

28 April 2015 - 29 April 2015

European Commission Work Forum CRPD implementation

29 Maart 2015 - 02 April 2015

UN CRPD Committee - 13th session

11 December 2014 - 14 December 2014

ENUSP General Assembly Hillerod 2014

14 Juli 2014 - 17 Juli 2014

Human Rights Committee 111 session July 2014

29 Maart 2014 - 05 April 2014

UN CRPD Committee sessions April 2014

09 Maart 2014 - 15 Maart 2014

HRC in Geneva and FGC in Zagreb

29 Januari 2014 - 01 Februari 2014

Empowerment Congress at WHO Europe CC

08 December 2013 - 11 December 2013

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2013 Bucharest

28 November 2013 - 01 December 2013

Starting FGC in Moldova - user/survivor initiative

29 Oktober 2013 - 02 November 2013

European Network for Family Group Conferencing

15 Juli 2013 - 20 Juli 2013

Conference of State Parties - New York 2013

12 Mei 2013 - 18 Mei 2013

CAT review of the Netherlands 2013

10 Maart 2013 - 15 Maart 2013

Rights into Action - training in Moldova

12 December 2012 - 16 December 2012

Expert meeting on torture- Washington DC

13 November 2012 - 14 November 2012

ENUSP MHE-Mapping Exclusion at European Parliament

05 November 2012 - 08 November 2012

London 5-8 November 2012

19 Oktober 2012 - 21 Oktober 2012

ENUSP Empowerment seminar in Zagreb

15 Juli 2012 - 28 Juli 2012

MDAC Summerschool 2012

12 Juni 2012 - 12 Juni 2012

ENUSP at EU Social Platform of NGO's

10 Mei 2012 - 11 Mei 2012

CAT session on Czech Republic - UN Geneva

14 December 2011 - 17 December 2011

OHCHR regional consultation on torture

11 Oktober 2011 - 01 November 2011

Zuid Afrika 2011

14 April 2010 - 18 April 2010

Praag - Building Bridges- Horatio

19 Oktober 2009 - 25 Oktober 2009

Congres in Stockholm

15 Maart 2009 - 30 Maart 2009

Oost Afrika 2009

29 Mei 2007 - 01 Juni 2007

WHO in Geneve, Zwitserland

03 Mei 2007 - 08 Mei 2007

Madrid - documentaire opnemen

07 Januari 2007 - 08 Februari 2007

Oost Afrika 2007

Landen bezocht: