EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU - Reisverslag uit Brussel, België van Jolijn Santegoeds - EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU - Reisverslag uit Brussel, België van Jolijn Santegoeds -

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

Door: Jolijn Santegoeds

Blijf op de hoogte en volg Jolijn

17 Mei 2016 | België, Brussel

On Tuesday 17 May 2016, I participated in the EESC hearing on the Concluding Observations of the UN CRPD Committee to the European Union- A new strategy for persons with disabilities in the European Union, also see . The meeting took place at the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) in Brussels from 9.30 AM till 1 PM. I was representing the European Network of (Ex) Users and Survivors of Psychiatry (ENUSP,

I arrived during the opening session, after an early morning train ride, and I was just in time to hear Yannis Vardakastanis, Rapporteur SOC/538 (and president of EDF), speak about the present opportunities to put the rights of persons with disabilities on the European agenda, and the need to go beyond business as usual. He highlighted several European developments, such as the European Disability Strategy, web accessibility and the European Accessibility Act, and he stressed the need for meaningful involvement and full participation of persons with disabilities through their representative organizations, in a structural dialogue at all levels of policy making. The EESC Committee (SOC/538) will prepare an own opinion report on the implementation of the CRPD and the Concluding Observations to the EU, which will be ready next month. This meetings aims to give input to that report.

The first panel zoomed in on several European developments with representatives of various EU bodies.

Emmanuelle Grange of the European Commission (EC) elaborated on the steps the European Commission is taking, such as their withdrawal from the EU Monitoring Framework to guarantee the independence of monitoring, the progress on the European Accessibility Act, and the revision of the European Disability Strategy including post-2020 ambitions. The EUs declaration of competence is still being worked on, because this is a more complex process.
She also highlighted the importance of de-institutionalization and the new conditions and monitoring on the use of European Social Funds. Also the role and input of NGOs and DPOs in ECs decision-making is not yet clarified nor subject to any binding legal structure, while support to and from NGOs and DPOs is important, so this is also a point of attention for the European Commission.

Helga Stevens of the European Parliament (EP) spoke about the actions of the European Parliament since EUs ratification of the UN CRPD. The European Parliament also made an own report, which was sent to the European Commission as input for the official EU report to the UN CRPD Committee. In response to the Concluding Observations, the EP will also produce an own initiative report, expected 7 July for plenary voting in the European Parliament, and an informative event is being planned in paralel. It is interesting to see that there are over 10 EC Committees involved in the reporting, which is 50% of the total, while usually there are only 1 or 2 committees involved in any topic. Now there is a high response, and a lot of involvement from both the European Commission and the European Parliament, which is positive. Coordination is of course needed.

Rosita Agnew of the European Ombudsman spoke about the complaints that persons can lodge at the European Ombudsman , which only deals with the performance of EU institutions itself, and stressed that there are still a low number of complaints received related to disability. She stressed that the European Ombudsman is willing to deal with disability-related complaints, yet the procedure seems under-used by persons with disabilities. The EU wants to be a role model in implementing the UN CRPD, which is the first human rights convention the EU has ever ratified. Interaction with civil society is needed.

Ciara O’Brien, head of COHOM, Council of the EU, spoke about external EU actions and foreign policies on human rights and democracy. She mentioned that the EU delegation had played a big role in the negotiations of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the agenda 2030, which now include about 17 targets for persons with disabilities.

Michael O’Flaherty of EUs Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA) spoke to us by a short video message, and emphasized the richness of knowledge that the CRPD has brought forward in the past 10 years, and highlighted the need for new laws and policies. FRA offers guidance by their research on issues and reforms that are relevant for the human rights of persons with disabilities in the EU.

As a last speaker of the first panel, Catherine Naughton of the European Disability Forum (EDF) briefly reflected on the 3 issues that the UN CRPD Committee had identified for follow-up in 1 year, which were 1. The independence of the EU Monitoring Framework, which has been taken care of by the immediate withdrawal of the European Commission. 2. The European Accessibility Act, which has also been made public for consultation and following adoption. And 3. The EUs declaration of competence is still being worked on. The review is giving a momentum, and the progress is positive, yet there is still also a need for European non-discrimination legislation, and it is recommended to re-open the consultation and adoption-process for EUs Equal Treatment Directive.

There was just a little bit of time for a few questions, and then there was a 12 minute coffee break.
The second panel started with Didier Dupre who spoke on behalf of EUROSTAT, about the ongoing revision of EUROSTAT’s tools in light of the UN CRPD and the social model. Several disability modules will be periodically added to existing European Social Surveys (such as SILC and EHIS).

Then Adriana van Dooijeweert of the European Network of National Human Rights Institutions (ENNHRI) spoke about the areas of focus: equal treatment, employment, accessibility and standard of living, and gave several examples of good and bad practices. She also mentioned the Sustainable Development Goals, and named a few targets that include the rights of persons with disabilities, while raising the concern that the SDGs still need more human rights based approach, for example refugees are not even mentioned.

A bit later, in the question time, I addressed a concern to her on the rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities in the SDGs, and my concerns seemed to find recognition by several participants, notably including ENNHRI and Inclusion Europe.

Veronique Ghesquiere of the Belgian Centre for Equal Opportunities (UNIA) reported on their work on complaints, concerns, awareness raising, and giving opinions and recommendations in law reforms. Unia was involved in the parallel report on Belgium to the UN CRPD Committee in 2014, and the concluding observations were firm against segregated education, and also against confinement in institutions such as psychiatry. It called for de-institutionalization of the sector, yet the Belgian society appears not ready yet for this change, so UNIA is continuing the debate with all stakeholders. In December 2016, during the celebration of the 10th anniversary of the UN CRPD, a tender for awareness raising will be launched, particularly focussing on the rights of persons with intellectual disabilities.

There was a little bit of time for questions, and then the floor was given to a number of representatives of the DPOs that had submitted a shadowreport for the EU review by the UN CRPD Committee last year. Every representative had 3 minutes to present their views.

Autism Europe emphasized that the Concluding Observations are good, but much work remains to be done to put these in practice.
The European Union of the Deaf (EUD) called for access to information, accessible formats and the needed recognition of sign language at the national and international level, including at the European level of legislation and policy making.

On behalf of the European Network of (Ex) Users and Survivors of Psychiatry (ENUSP), I called on the EU to make objections against the declarations issued by several EU members states on articles 12, 15 and 25, which are limiting the rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities. Also ENUSP calls on the EU to issue a moratorium on substitute decision-making, forced treatments and forced institutionalization, and apply this prohibition to all member states.

The European Association of Service Providers for Persons with Disabilities (EASPD) stressed the need for a structural long term planning for implementation of the CRPD, and asked for better recognition of the role of support providers, because if services are not available, persons are not able to access or exercise their rights.

The European Network on Independent Living (ENIL) emphasized the impact of austerity measures on persons with disabilities, in their daily lives as well as in terms of organizing in DPOs. Remuneration should be in place for the systematic consultation of DPOs. For successful implementation, it is essential to have clear definitions of key terms, such as independent living, de-institutionalization, support and personal assistance.

Inclusion Europe emphasized that meaningful consultation of persons with intellectual disabilities depends on support and assistance as well as accessibility of information, and a focal point should carry responsibility. Equality and non-discrimination are very important themes in the lives of persons with intellectual disabilities and their families, and capacity building of persons with disabilities and their organizations is needed.

The International Disability and Development Consortium (IDDC) highlighted the duty to leave nobody behind, and called for a workplan to be developed with DPOs. For example, the support to refugees does not take into account accessibility needs, and while we recognize that a lot is being done for refugees, there is no reason to exclude refugees with disabilities.

The International Federation for Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus (IF) highlighted that EUs health programme lacks the disability angle. Also 3 messages from IF’s youth group were shared: 1. More attention to the financial situation of persons with disabilities, young and old. 2. Access of opportunities and 3. More chances for participation, including by stimulating young people with disabilities to get into politics, which is one of the firmest ways to secure the rights of persons with disabilities in legislation, policy and practice.

By then it was already past 1 PM and there was no time left for general conclusions by the organizers. However, a closed meeting was to continue in the afternoon, where the outcomes of the meeting this morning would be taken into account.

On my way out, I met the Dutch chair of Dutch NHRI who had been presenting on behalf of the ENNHRI. It was quite nice, and we seemed to have a number of views in common, which kind of surprised me positively. But when I asked her about possibilities for support concerning my personal struggle against human right violations in the Netherlands, this appeared “likely impossible to deal with individual complaints”, which I found very disappointing again (and it basically ruined my day to hear this rejection again).

After all, I said goodbye to all, and I left to travel back home with the train. It had been quite an interesting meeting, and I am sincerely hoping that the EU is not giving false hope, and that bureaucracy and the list of EUs competence will not exclude the fundamental rights of persons with psychosocial disabilities. I hope the EU will indeed prove to be a role model and a champion in human rights implementation. I am sincerely hoping that. Time will tell...

Reageer op dit reisverslag

Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley


rondreizen en ontdekken hoe mensen met psychiatrische problemen overal (over)leven en kijken waarmee we elkaar kunnen helpen.

Actief sinds 21 Dec. 2006
Verslag gelezen: 891
Totaal aantal bezoekers 695121

Voorgaande reizen:

05 Juni 2019 - 06 Juni 2019

Council of Europe - Bioethics Ctee 6 June 2019

12 Mei 2019 - 13 Mei 2019

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2019

08 Oktober 2018 - 10 Oktober 2018

Global Ministerial Mental Health Summit

20 Juni 2018 - 24 Juni 2018

Trieste congres June 2018

10 Juni 2018 - 15 Juni 2018

COSP CRPD 2018 New York

28 Mei 2018 - 29 Mei 2018

EC Work Forum on UN CRPD implementation 2018

25 Mei 2018 - 28 Mei 2018

EDF General Assembly 2018 Vilnius

02 Maart 2018 - 04 Maart 2018

EDF Board meeting Brussels 2018

23 September 1994 - 16 Februari 2018

seeking access to justice in NL

05 Februari 2018 - 15 Februari 2018

5th Global Mental Health Summit, SA 2018

06 Oktober 2017 - 09 Oktober 2017

EDF Board meeting in Tallinn

11 Juni 2017 - 25 Juni 2017

COSP NY and Summerschool Galway

06 Juni 2017 - 07 Juni 2017

Council of Europe - Bioethics Committee meeting

18 Mei 2017 - 19 Mei 2017

European Commission Workforum on UN CRPD

11 Mei 2017 - 14 Mei 2017

EDF General Assembly 2017 Madrid

10 Maart 2017 - 14 Maart 2017

WHOCC conference on coercion - Paris 2017

17 Februari 2017 - 19 Februari 2017

EDF Board meeting 2017 Malta

24 November 2016 - 30 November 2016

INTAR India 2016

13 November 2016 - 16 November 2016

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar Berlin 2016

12 Oktober 2016 - 15 Oktober 2016

Expert meeting on the Right to Mental Health

26 September 2016 - 26 September 2016

Personal meeting with MEP Helga Stevens

14 September 2016 - 16 September 2016

5th European Conference on Mental Health

09 Augustus 2016 - 11 Augustus 2016

visit to Lister and ENIK Recovery College

22 Juni 2016 - 24 Juni 2016

NUI Galway Summer School Int. Disability Law

12 Juni 2016 - 18 Juni 2016

Conference of State Parties UN CRPD

09 Juni 2016 - 10 Juni 2016

EC Workforum on CRPD implementation

20 Mei 2016 - 22 Mei 2016

EDF Annual General Assembly 2016 in Dublin

17 Mei 2016 - 17 Mei 2016

EESC Hearing on CRPD Concluding Observations to EU

09 April 2016 - 12 April 2016

WNUSP taskforce meeting and CRPD Committee

11 Maart 2016 - 13 Maart 2016

EDF board meeting Amsterdam 11-13 March 2016

13 December 2015 - 15 December 2015

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2015 Brussels

26 Oktober 2015 - 01 November 2015

Meetings in Brussels and Paris

26 Augustus 2015 - 29 Augustus 2015

EU review at 14th CRPD session in Geneva

15 Juli 2015 - 30 Juli 2015

Human rights work in Japan

01 Juni 2015 - 02 Juni 2015

EASPD Hearing at European Parliament

29 Mei 2015 - 31 Mei 2015

EDF General Assembly 2015 Warsaw

28 April 2015 - 29 April 2015

European Commission Work Forum CRPD implementation

29 Maart 2015 - 02 April 2015

UN CRPD Committee - 13th session

11 December 2014 - 14 December 2014

ENUSP General Assembly Hillerod 2014

14 Juli 2014 - 17 Juli 2014

Human Rights Committee 111 session July 2014

29 Maart 2014 - 05 April 2014

UN CRPD Committee sessions April 2014

09 Maart 2014 - 15 Maart 2014

HRC in Geneva and FGC in Zagreb

29 Januari 2014 - 01 Februari 2014

Empowerment Congress at WHO Europe CC

08 December 2013 - 11 December 2013

ENUSP Empowerment Seminar 2013 Bucharest

28 November 2013 - 01 December 2013

Starting FGC in Moldova - user/survivor initiative

29 Oktober 2013 - 02 November 2013

European Network for Family Group Conferencing

15 Juli 2013 - 20 Juli 2013

Conference of State Parties - New York 2013

12 Mei 2013 - 18 Mei 2013

CAT review of the Netherlands 2013

10 Maart 2013 - 15 Maart 2013

Rights into Action - training in Moldova

12 December 2012 - 16 December 2012

Expert meeting on torture- Washington DC

13 November 2012 - 14 November 2012

ENUSP MHE-Mapping Exclusion at European Parliament

05 November 2012 - 08 November 2012

London 5-8 November 2012

19 Oktober 2012 - 21 Oktober 2012

ENUSP Empowerment seminar in Zagreb

15 Juli 2012 - 28 Juli 2012

MDAC Summerschool 2012

12 Juni 2012 - 12 Juni 2012

ENUSP at EU Social Platform of NGO's

10 Mei 2012 - 11 Mei 2012

CAT session on Czech Republic - UN Geneva

14 December 2011 - 17 December 2011

OHCHR regional consultation on torture

11 Oktober 2011 - 01 November 2011

Zuid Afrika 2011

14 April 2010 - 18 April 2010

Praag - Building Bridges- Horatio

19 Oktober 2009 - 25 Oktober 2009

Congres in Stockholm

15 Maart 2009 - 30 Maart 2009

Oost Afrika 2009

29 Mei 2007 - 01 Juni 2007

WHO in Geneve, Zwitserland

03 Mei 2007 - 08 Mei 2007

Madrid - documentaire opnemen

07 Januari 2007 - 08 Februari 2007

Oost Afrika 2007

Landen bezocht: